6/25/10 Whisky Tasting – Speyside vs. Campbeltown
#1 Glenfarclas 10yr
Strength: 43%
Appearance: Golden and shimmery, a wee bit yellow
Nose: molasses, malteasers, sherry, a little earth
Body: medium
Palate: Very light on the initial sip and incredibly smooth, a little oily, creamy, this ones a grower, the longer you hold it, the more that it fizzes like sucking on a pepperdew, instead of eating it immediately. Perhaps a little bitter citrus in there.
Finish: Delightfully understated, a real grower which seems feeble at first, but sticks around on every inch of your gullet accumulating more warmth the with each sip.
#2 Kilkerran – Work in Progress
Strength: 46%
Appearance: Iight yellow and very cloudy
Nose: sea salt, lots of seaweed, this smells like the West coast, reminds me of fish and chips, harbours and a boat called Fart (or Bram in Gàidhlig)
Body: medium/light
Palate: On first sip it is surprisingly tame and lacks the evil stereotypical of younger whiskies. This is an “accumulator” and the salt is much more understated than the nose would initially suggest. Peat starts to stick to your tongue after several sips, which leads to a promising finish
Finish: A little jewel of warmth on a cloudy day. I say that this whisky has promise.
#3 Balvenie Doublewood 12yr
Strength: 43%
Appearance: Amber, gold and a little cloudy
Nose: Very light, needs a little warming, then a little caramel, fizzy on your nose hairs, really sweet like candied dates
Body: Light
Palate: At first it’s very fizzy and warm, with a tingle at the end of the tongue, some citrus and yummy malt. Some mild floral undertones. Fully rounded tongue fun, with long-lasting results, which you can explore for ages!
Finish: you can still taste it right now.
#4 Longrow CV
Strength: 46%
Appearance: Quite similar to Kilkerran, more frosty and opaque
Nose: peat and salt. A bit closed, benefits from warming, then some sweeter honey tones and a little melon comes in.
Body: Medium
Palate: Man is this oily! The peat is there but it isn’t OTT. Instead it is salty and has some delightfully sweet and seaweed-like tones. The throat is pretty smooth with some residual peat smoke added in.
Finish: Some interesting smoke, with warm in the pit of your chest.




















